Personal Injury Settlements
Pain and Suffering with Broken Finger and Surgery

Last year, I was in a car accident which was entirely the fault of the other driver.

My car was totaled and my right pinky finger was broken (I am right-handed).

For about 3-4 weeks after the accident, each time I drove, I would have at least one episode of extreme anxiety. Now, 7 months afterwards, it has decreased to once per 1-2 weeks.

I was planning on driving to join my family for a vacation a few days later, but of course I had to cancel after the accident.

The fracture required surgery, and I wore a cast over my hand and wrist for about 4 weeks total. Since I am right-handed, my everyday activities were extremely limited.

Right before the accident, my job assignment had ended, so I was officially out of work. On the day of my surgery, I received a job offer, but I was forced to turn it down since I was unable to begin work when they needed me.

Initially after the surgery, I was completely unable to move my finger. I did exercises 3x/day, at home and at physical therapy, in which I was instructed by the doctor to reach “the point of pain and beyond”—and he was right, the pain was so excruciating that I was involuntarily kicking my feet—but I kept at it.

After about 8-9 weeks of therapy, my mobility had improved greatly, and I was almost back to my previous ability. But even now, 3 months later, I still can’t straighten or bend my finger completely, my typing has more errors since my finger is stiff, and my finger cramps up after writing for a while. Typing and writing were both activities I spent a great deal of time doing beforehand, both for work and as a hobby. My fingers do not look symmetrical anymore—the lower half of my pinky is fatter, the finger is slightly crooked, and there is scarring.


The medical expenses totaled about $24,000. I used the personal injury calculator on this website (the property damage part was not included, since it has been taken care of) and it gave the answer that my claim is worth $72,000 to $120,000.

I wanted to confirm with you to see if you think this sounds like an appropriate amount.

What should I set as
1. An initial demand amount and
2. An amount I should expect to settle with in the end?

Any advice would be greatly appreciated.

Thanks for reading!




Comments for Personal Injury Settlements
Pain and Suffering with Broken Finger and Surgery

Click here to add your own comments

Feb 24, 2011
Help with Personal Injury Settlement Amount
by: Anonymous

Sorry to hear about your injuries. Before I begin I want to let you know that I am not a lawyer and this is not any form legal advice.

Here is what I would do:

From what you have described about your pain and suffering I think the range of $72,000 - $120,000 is a good start. But remember these are rough estimates. The specifics of your case will adjust your range.

You mentioned how your injuries prevented you from getting a job. If you can prove this ( like with an interview date and expected salary) you definitely increase your chances of getting a higher settlement.

As far as how much you will get in the end, that is tough to determine so early. It will depend on how well you present evidence of your pain and suffering and how well you can negotiate.

(Start with Negotiating Car Accident Injury Settlements to get an idea of what to expect.)

My guess would be that you should expect somewhere in the middle range($90,000 - $100,000). But again this is without knowing the specifics.

I would suggest you have a price in mind that you would be happy with before you start negotiating. Then if you are unsatisfied, you can always bring in a personal injury lawyer. You can tell the injury lawyer that they will only get money if they can get you above what you were already expecting. This way you don't spend too much on legal counsel.

Hope that helps. Please come back and tell us how it turned out. Best of luck!

Click here to add your own comments

Join in and write your own page! It's easy to do. How? Simply click here to return to Personal Injury Settlement Amount Stories.